On Tradition, Cockfighting and Education

"A Ban on Cockfighting, but the Tradition Lives On," by Adam B. Ellick in today’s New York Times, raises several important questions for me.

Let’s deconstruct:

• I was left wondering whether when cockfighting is made illegal, there’s any kind of humane education component to the law. Unless there is an education component, where the current and future
  generations of chicken torturers have the opportunity to examine what
  they’re doing and why, and learn about who chickens are and what
  they’re capable of (i.e., sentience), you’re only treating the symptom.
  You can chase people who have already bred and are already using the
  chickens all day long, but until they realize that tradition isn’t a
  valid justification for their form of "entertainment" and profit,
  eradicating cockfighting will never happen. It’ll keep getting passed from generation to generation, as if it’s a perfectly acceptable thing to do.
• If you tell people they’re not allowed to continue a brutal practice they think they’re entitled to practice due to "tradition" or "culture" (translation: there’s no good reason to do it other than they want to), of course you should plan on them going underground with it. Laws should come with budgets that make their enforcement possible.
• Not surprisingly, the article has references to "animal rights advocates," as if we’re the only ones who object to cockfighting. But I’m pretty sure the average veal-eating, purebreed-owning person on my street has a problem with it, too.
• Finally, you know how when there’s pressure to close a Greyhound track, racing supporters cry: But what about all of the jobs that will be lost? Here’s a great response by an animal control investigator after the courts in New Mexico dismissed a lawsuit by the New Mexico Gamefowl Association claiming economic devastation after the ban: “You need to go find a job at Wal-Mart." There’s easy money in every community, and often it is made at someone else’s expense. Children need to be having that discussion with their parents and at school so they don’t grow up believing they can harm whomever they want, even to support their families.

Ed Lowry, a director of the New Mexico Gamefowl Association said, “A gamecock shows me what an American should be like. You defend to the death.” No, Mr. Lowry, the gamecock defends to the death, and you walk away, making money from his suffering, his blood and his mutilation. Is that what an American should be like?